Every Charlotte home needs cooling, so the real question is what provides the heat: the same outdoor unit running in reverse (a heat pump), a gas furnace, or both (dual fuel). Charlotte's normal January low is just under freezing and its normal January high is in the low 50s, and the U.S. Department of Energy says air-source heat pumps can be used in all climates. A gas furnace suits homes that already have gas and ducts sized for it. What you have now usually decides which is cheaper to install.
The three setups
What Charlotte's climate record says
The National Weather Service publishes 30-year normals for Charlotte, covering 1991 to 2020.
Two things follow. First, cooling is the bigger job here: summer is long and hot, and whatever you buy, its cooling side will run for more of the year than its heating side. Second, a normal winter night bottoms out around freezing and the days climb back into the 50s. Those are averages, and colder nights do occur, but this is not a climate where the heating system fights deep cold for months.
What the U.S. Department of Energy says about heat pumps
From the Department of Energy's Energy Saver Guide:
- Heat pumps are the most efficient form of electric heating, providing up to three times more heat than the energy they use.
- They can cut electricity use for heating by about half compared with electric furnaces or baseboard heaters.
- Air-source heat pumps are the most common type and can be used in all climates.
- If the thermostat is set back by hand in a way that brings on the backup electric-resistance heat, that heat is more expensive to run. Use a thermostat designed for a heat pump.
That guide compares heat pumps with electric resistance heat, not with gas. Whether a heat pump or a gas furnace costs less to run in your house depends on your electricity and gas rates and on how efficient each unit is. We have not found a sourced comparison for Charlotte rates, so we do not give one. Ask each contractor to show the arithmetic for your house, using the rates on your own bills.
What you have now decides most of the cost
You have a heat pump today
Replacing it with another heat pump reuses the wiring, the ducts and the refrigerant line route. Switching to gas means a gas service to the house if there is none, gas piping to the furnace, a flue, and a different indoor unit. That is a larger job with more trades.
You have a gas furnace and air conditioner today
You can replace like with like, or change the outdoor unit to a heat pump and keep a furnace as the backup, which is dual fuel. Going all-electric means removing the furnace and fitting an air handler with electric backup heat, which may need a larger electrical circuit. Ask whether your electrical panel can take it, and what it costs if not.
Your ducts
Ducts are sized for the system they were built with, and they are the part of the job most often left out of quotes. Ask each contractor whether they measured the duct system, whether it suits the equipment they are proposing, and what duct sealing or changes are included. The Department of Energy guide says a contractor should give you the calculations used to size the system. Ask to see them.
Rules that apply in Charlotte
- Permit. Replacing a heating or air-conditioning system needs a permit in North Carolina at any price. Mecklenburg County requires separate permits for heating and air-conditioning, electrical and plumbing work, so a change of fuel can add permits. The office is Code Enforcement, 980-314-CODE (2633).
- License. Heating and cooling work needs a state license with no dollar minimum, and so does electrical contracting. The county will not issue the permit to an unlicensed installer.
- Where the outdoor unit can sit. Charlotte's zoning ordinance says ground-mounted or wall-mounted mechanical equipment for single-family homes may not be placed in the setback along a street frontage, and may extend into a required side or rear setback by no more than half that setback's width. If a new system means moving the outdoor unit, check the spot before the pad is poured. Towns outside the city have their own rules.
Our permit guide covers the permit rule in more detail.
How to choose
A heat pump tends to suit you if:
- You have a heat pump now, or no gas service at the house
- You want one fuel and one piece of outdoor equipment
- You are replacing an electric furnace or baseboard heat, where the Department of Energy puts the saving at about half
A gas furnace with an air conditioner tends to suit you if:
- You have gas service, a flue and ducts sized for a furnace already
- You prefer the warmer air a furnace delivers at the register
- A like-for-like swap keeps the job simple
Dual fuel tends to suit you if:
- You have gas now and want the heat pump to carry the mild days, with the furnace for the coldest ones
- You accept higher equipment cost and two systems to maintain
Whichever you lean toward, ask at least one contractor to price the alternative. The difference between two written quotes for your own house is worth more than any general rule.
Questions to put to every contractor
- Which setup are you quoting, and why that one for this house?
- What size is the equipment, and can I see the sizing calculation?
- What are the model numbers of the outdoor unit, the indoor unit and the thermostat?
- For a heat pump: how much backup heat is included, and at what outdoor temperature is it set to come on?
- For dual fuel: at what outdoor temperature does the system switch to gas, and who sets that?
- What work is included on the ducts?
- Which permits are you pulling, and is the fee in the price?
- Does my electrical panel or gas line need any change?
Our guide on why HVAC quotes differ explains how to compare the answers, and repair or replace covers whether you need a new system at all.
How QuoteFlash fits in
Tell our agent what system you have, what fuel, and that you are weighing the options. The agent works for you. It matches you with up to five local contractors who are insured, and licensed where the state requires it. Their written quotes arrive in one place, and the agent explains the differences in plain terms, including which setup each contractor proposed. You choose which contractors get your phone number. Free for homeowners; contractors pay when matched. See heating and cooling quotes in the Charlotte area.