Home / Guides

How to compare contractor quotes

Three contractors look at one job and hand you three very different numbers. Usually nobody is lying. They are quoting different jobs.

The short answer

Do not compare the totals first. Line the quotes up and check that each one covers the same work, the same materials and the same extras. Most of the gap between a high quote and a low one is work that one contractor priced and the other left out. Once the quotes describe the same job, the price difference that remains is the real one.

This guide works for any home project: a roof, a heating and cooling system, windows, a water heater, siding, a bathroom, flooring, a fence or a deck.

Before you ask for quotes

Write the job down once and give every contractor the same description. Include what you want done, what you want kept, anything you already know is wrong, and any deadline. If one contractor suggests a change you like, tell the others and ask them to reprice. Quotes for different jobs cannot be compared, however carefully you read them.

Estimate, quote or bid?

Contractors use these words loosely. What matters is whether the price is fixed. Ask directly: "Is this the price I will pay if nothing changes, or a rough figure?" Get the answer in writing on the document itself.

The 12 lines to find on every quote

1. Scope of work

A plain description of what will be done, start to finish, including removal of the old material, disposal and cleanup. "Replace roof" is not a scope. "Remove one layer of shingles to the deck, install new underlayment, flashing and shingles, haul away debris" is.

2. Materials, by name

Brand, product line and model number. For equipment, the size and efficiency rating too. "Architectural shingles" or "3-ton heat pump" could describe products at very different prices. If a quote does not name the product, ask for it before you compare.

3. Quantities and measurements

Squares of roofing, linear feet of fence, square feet of flooring, number of windows. If two contractors measured the same house and got different numbers, ask both how they measured. One of them is wrong, and you want to know which before the work starts.

4. What is not included

Good quotes list their exclusions. Common ones: repairs to anything found behind or under the old material, painting and trim, moving furniture, electrical upgrades, and haul-away. An exclusion is not a problem. A missing exclusions list is, because you do not know what the contractor assumed.

5. Allowances and unit prices for surprises

Some costs cannot be known until work starts, such as rotten roof decking or a damaged subfloor. A careful quote either includes an allowance or gives a unit price, for example a price per sheet of decking replaced. Without one, the price of a surprise gets set after your roof is already off.

6. Permit and inspections

Does the job need a permit, who applies, and is the fee in the price? In North Carolina a heating and cooling replacement needs a permit at any price, while many roof, window and siding replacements under $40,000 do not. Our permit guide for Charlotte and Mecklenburg County lists the rules by project. A quote that skips a required permit is cheaper for a reason.

7. License and insurance details

The quote or its cover page should show the business's legal name, address, license number where a license applies, and proof of liability coverage. North Carolina requires a general contractor license for jobs of $40,000 or more, and a trade license for heating, cooling and plumbing at any price. Look the number up with the state board yourself. It takes a minute.

8. Who does the work

The contractor's own crew or a subcontractor? Who is on site each day, and who do you call with a question? Neither answer is wrong. You should know which it is.

9. Start date and duration

An expected start date, how long the work takes, and what could move it (weather, material lead times, inspections). "As soon as possible" cannot be compared with a date.

10. Payment schedule

How much is due at signing, during the work and at the end. Look for a final payment that is due only after the work is finished and any required inspection has passed. A schedule that asks for most of the money before work starts shifts the risk to you.

11. Warranties

There are usually two. The manufacturer covers the product. The contractor covers the installation. Check the length of each, what voids it, whether the manufacturer's warranty must be registered and who registers it, and get the contractor's workmanship warranty in writing.

12. Changes, and how long the price holds

How are changes priced and approved once work starts? Look for a rule that changes are agreed in writing, with a price, before the extra work is done. Also check the date the quote expires.

Putting quotes side by side

  1. Make a grid: the twelve lines down the side, one column per contractor.
  2. Fill in what each quote says. Leave a blank where it says nothing.
  3. Send each contractor their blanks as questions. Ask for the answers in writing.
  4. Adjust for differences in scope. If one quote includes haul-away and another does not, ask the second for the price to add it.
  5. Now compare totals.

How contractors handle step 3 tells you something. One who answers plainly and updates the quote is showing you how the job will go.

What a much lower quote usually means

A quote well below the others is not automatically a bad one. It usually comes down to one of these:

  • Less work. An overlay instead of a tear-off. Reusing old flashing, ductwork or trim.
  • Lower-grade materials. A cheaper product line, or a product that is not named at all.
  • Nothing set aside for surprises. No allowance and no unit price, so the extra arrives later as a change.
  • No permit where one is required.
  • A smaller business with lower overhead. This one is a fair reason to be cheaper.

Fill in the grid and you will see which it is.

What a much higher quote usually means

  • More work included, such as full replacement where others priced a partial one.
  • Higher-grade materials or longer warranties.
  • A larger company with more overhead.
  • Sometimes, simply a higher price for the same job.

Ask the contractor to walk you through what their price includes that the others do not. If they cannot point to anything, you have your answer.

Warning signs

  • The price is only good if you sign today.
  • No written quote, or a total with no detail behind it.
  • The business will not give a legal name, address or license number.
  • The contractor suggests skipping a permit the job requires.
  • Payment in full before work begins.

Trade-specific things to check

How QuoteFlash helps with this

QuoteFlash does the side-by-side for you. You describe the project to our agent, which works for you, not for the contractors. It matches you with up to five local contractors who are insured, and licensed where the state requires it. Their written quotes land in one place, and the agent explains where they differ and what each one leaves out. You can ask the contractors questions before any of them has your phone number, and you choose who gets it. Contractors pay QuoteFlash when they are matched. You pay nothing.

Questions about comparing quotes

How many quotes should I get?

Enough to see a pattern. With two quotes you cannot tell which one is unusual. With three to five you can. QuoteFlash matches you with up to five.

Why are quotes for the same job so far apart?

Mostly because they are not for the same job. Scope, material grade, allowances for hidden damage and the permit account for most of the gap. Overhead and how busy the contractor is account for the rest.

Should I take the lowest quote?

Only after you know why it is lowest. If it covers the same work with the same materials and the contractor is properly licensed and insured, a lower price is a fair reason to choose it.

Is it OK to tell a contractor what the others quoted?

Yes. You can share another quote's scope without sharing its price, and ask them to match the scope so you can compare. Whether to share prices is your choice.

What if a quote is just one line and a total?

Ask for the detail in writing. If the contractor will not provide it, you have nothing to hold them to later.

Can a contractor change the price after I sign?

Only as the contract allows. That is why line 12 matters: changes should be priced and agreed in writing before the extra work is done.

One minute now. Up to five quotes to compare.

Get my quotesFree, no obligation, and you choose who gets your number
Contractor in the Charlotte area?Get matched with verified homeowners who are ready for quotes.
Apply for your area