Before you look at totals, check ten lines on each roof quote: roof size, tear-off, decking, underlayment, flashing, shingles, ventilation, cleanup, permit and warranty. Most of the gap between two roof quotes sits in the first three. One roofer measured more roof, priced a full tear-off, or set a price for rotten decking, and the other did not.
This page covers only the lines that are specific to a roof. Payment schedule, start date, who does the work and how changes are priced apply to every trade, and they are in our general guide on how to read a contractor quote.
The ten roof lines
1. Roof size, in squares
Roofers price by the square. One square is 100 square feet of roof surface, not floor area. Every material and labor line is multiplied by this number, so it is the first thing to compare. If two quotes show different numbers of squares for the same house, ask each roofer how the roof was measured, on the roof or from aerial imagery, and how much was added for waste. One of the numbers is wrong, and it moves the whole price.
2. Tear-off
The quote should say that the existing roofing comes off down to the wood deck, how many layers are there now, and that hauling and disposal are included. North Carolina's state guidance on re-roofing, quoting the residential code, describes roof replacement as including removal of the existing layers of roof covering down to the roof deck. A quote that lays new shingles over old ones is a different job. It cannot be compared with a tear-off quote on price.
3. Decking
The deck is the plywood or board sheathing under the shingles. Nobody can see its condition until the old roof is off, so this line decides whether your price is firm. Look for three things:
- A unit price for each sheet of decking replaced, stated in the quote.
- How many sheets, if any, are already included in the base price.
- How you will be told before extra sheets are replaced. Photos of the bad areas are a reasonable thing to ask for.
There is a North Carolina detail here that affects more than price. Under state guidance, a re-roof costing $40,000 or less needs no building permit, and that exemption covers replacing up to 15 percent of the existing roof deck. If far more of the deck turns out to be bad, the job is no longer a simple replacement. Ask each roofer what they do in that case. In South Carolina, the state's roofer registration is defined as work above the roof deck, so ask who is licensed for any decking or framing repair.
4. Underlayment
Underlayment is the layer between the deck and the shingles. The quote should name the product, say whether it is synthetic or felt, and say where self-adhering waterproof membrane goes, for example in valleys and around chimneys, pipes and skylights. "Underlayment included" tells you nothing you can compare.
5. Flashing and drip edge
Flashing is the metal that seals every place the roof meets something else. It is also where a lower quote most often differs, because reusing the old metal saves labor. For each of these, the quote should say new or reused:
- Step flashing where the roof meets a wall or dormer
- Chimney flashing and counter flashing
- Valley metal, if the valleys are open
- Pipe boots and vent collars
- Drip edge along the eaves and rakes
- Skylight flashing kits
Reuse is sometimes a fair call, such as flashing set behind brick. The roofer should be able to say why, item by item.
6. Shingles, starter and ridge cap
The quote should give the manufacturer, the product line and the color. "Architectural shingles" covers products at quite different prices. Then check the two pieces that finish the roof: the starter strip along the edges and the cap shingles on the ridges and hips. Ask whether these are the manufacturer's purpose-made products or cut from field shingles.
7. Ventilation
A re-roof is the one time attic ventilation is easy to change. The quote should say what is there now, what is being removed, and what is being installed: a ridge vent, box vents or a powered fan, and whether the intake vents at the soffits were checked. If one roofer adds a ridge vent and another does not mention ventilation at all, ask the second what they saw in the attic.
8. Protection and cleanup
Look for how landscaping, gutters, the driveway and the outdoor heating and cooling unit are protected, where the dumpster sits, and a magnetic sweep for nails at the end. These cost little, but a quote that lists them tells you how the crew works.
9. Permit and approvals
The quote should state whether the roofer assumed a permit. In North Carolina, a like-for-like re-roof at $40,000 or less generally needs no building permit; a job over $40,000 or one with structural repair does, and deck replacement beyond the 15 percent mark falls outside the exemption. The rules by project are in our permit guide for Charlotte and nearby towns. If you live in a community with an owners' association, a change of shingle color or type may need approval first. See HOA approval for exterior projects.
10. Warranty
Two warranties apply, and quotes blur them. Ask each roofer to write down:
- The name of the manufacturer's warranty offered, since most manufacturers have more than one level.
- Whether that level depends on using the same manufacturer's underlayment, starter and ridge cap, and whether the quote includes them.
- Who registers it, and whether you receive the confirmation.
- The length of the roofer's own workmanship warranty and what it covers, in writing.
What a much lower roof quote usually leaves out
A checklist to send each roofer
Copy these into one message and send it to every roofer who quoted. Ask for answers in writing.
- How many squares did you measure, how, and what waste allowance did you add?
- Is this a full tear-off to the deck? How many layers are on the roof now?
- What is your price per sheet of decking, and how many sheets are included?
- Which underlayment, and where does waterproof membrane go?
- Which flashing is new and which is reused?
- Which shingle, by manufacturer, line and color? Which starter and ridge cap?
- What ventilation is being removed and installed?
- Did you assume a permit? Why or why not?
- Which manufacturer warranty, who registers it, and what is your workmanship warranty?
Once every quote answers the same nine questions, the difference in price that remains is the real one. To see how the total is built from roof size and line items, read what drives roof replacement cost in Charlotte.
How QuoteFlash does this for you
On QuoteFlash you describe the roof to our agent, which works for you and not for the roofers. It matches you with up to five local contractors who are insured, and licensed where the state requires it. Their written quotes arrive in one place, and the agent lines them up on the points above and tells you what each one leaves out. Contractors pay when they are matched. You pay nothing. Start on our roof replacement page.