Check from the ground and from inside the attic, not from the roof. Write down what you see and take dated photos. Do not sign anything on the doorstep: a sale made at your home can generally be cancelled within three business days under a federal rule, but it is easier not to need it. Get more than one written quote, each stating whether it is a repair or a full replacement and why.
What to check, without climbing
You do not need to get on the roof, and after a storm you should not. From the ground, with binoculars or a phone camera zoomed in, walk all the way round the house and look for:
- Shingles on the ground, or pieces of them, in the yard or the gutters
- Gaps on the roof where shingles are missing, or a patch that is a different color because the layer below is showing
- Lifted, creased or folded shingles, especially along the ridge and at the edges
- Flashing around the chimney, vents and walls that has pulled away or bent
- Gutters and downspouts that are dented, loose or pulled off
- Dents in soft metal: roof vents, gutter faces, downspouts, the tops of outdoor heating and cooling units, mailboxes. Dents there after a hailstorm tell you the hail was large enough to mark metal, which is a reason to have the shingles looked at
- A build-up of dark granules at the bottom of downspouts, more than you normally see
- Fallen limbs on the roof, or scrape marks where one landed and slid off
Then go inside:
- Look at the ceilings of the top floor for new stains or damp spots
- In the attic, in daylight with the light off, look for points of daylight through the roof deck. With a flashlight, look for wet insulation, dark stains on the underside of the deck, or drips around vents and the chimney
Write down the date and time of the storm and take photos of everything, including the things that look fine. If water is coming in, a tarp over the area is a reasonable emergency step, and a roofer can do that as a small paid job on its own, without a contract for anything larger.
What damage needs and does not need
Not every storm means a new roof, and not every roof that looks fine from the ground is undamaged. In broad terms:
Ask anyone who inspects the roof for photos of what they found, slope by slope, with a note of where on the roof each was taken. A recommendation to replace the whole roof should come with evidence from more than one slope.
When someone knocks on your door
After hail or wind, roofing crews, some from outside the area, may work storm-hit neighborhoods door to door. Some are good roofers. Some will not be reachable in a year when a leak appears. You cannot tell which from the doorstep, so apply the same checks to everyone.
- Do not let a stranger onto your roof on the spot. Take a card and say you will be in touch.
- Ask for the legal business name and a local street address, and look both up yourself.
- Ask how long they have worked in the Charlotte area and for addresses of roofs they completed here in earlier years, not just this month.
- Ask for written proof of liability coverage, with the business's name on it.
- Ask about licensing. North Carolina requires a general contractor license when a job costs $40,000 or more. Ask which license they hold and check the number with the state board.
- Do not sign anything at the door, including a form described as permission to inspect. Read every page of anything you are handed, and keep a copy.
- Do not pay for the whole job before it starts.
- Be wary of a price that is only good today.
If you did sign at the door
The Federal Trade Commission's Cooling-Off Rule covers many sales of $25 or more made at your home. It gives you until midnight of the third business day after the sale to cancel for a full refund, and the seller must tell you about that right and give you two copies of a cancellation form with your contract. Saturdays count as business days; Sundays and federal holidays do not. If you were not given the forms, a dated cancellation letter postmarked within the three business days does the same job, and certified mail gives you proof. The rule has exceptions, including sales needed to meet an emergency and visits you asked for to repair something, so do not rely on it as your plan.
Permits for storm repairs in North Carolina
A roof replacement costing $40,000 or less on a single-family home needs no building permit under state law, and state guidance treats replacing up to 15 percent of the roof deck as part of a re-roof. A permit is required when the job is over $40,000, when more than 15 percent of the deck is replaced, or when rafters, trusses or other load-bearing parts are repaired. Storm damage is more likely than ordinary wear to involve the deck and the framing, so ask every roofer which side of that line your job is on. For Charlotte addresses the permit office is Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement, 980-314-CODE (2633). Details are in our permit guide.
What a storm repair or replacement quote should list
- Whether it is a repair or a full replacement, and the reason, with photos
- Which slopes or areas are included
- Tear-off down to the deck, or not
- A price per sheet for replacing damaged decking, and how much is assumed
- Underlayment, flashing, drip edge, vents and ridge: replaced or reused, and the product names
- Shingle manufacturer, product line and color, and for a repair, how closely the new shingles will match the old
- Gutters, if damaged: repair or replace
- Permit: needed or not, and who applies
- Cleanup, including a magnet sweep for nails
- Manufacturer warranty and the roofer's own workmanship warranty, in writing
- Start date, duration and payment schedule
Our guide to comparing roof replacement quotes line by line goes through each of these.
How QuoteFlash fits in
Tell our agent what happened and what you have seen. The agent works for you, not for the roofers. It matches you with up to five local contractors who are insured, and licensed where the state requires it. Their written quotes arrive in one place, and the agent explains where they differ, including which recommend repair and which recommend replacement. You choose which contractors get your phone number. Homeowners pay nothing. Contractors pay when they are matched. See roof repair and replacement quotes in the Charlotte area.